Mennonite head coverings why

Why did we start refusing certain types of head coverings as not being acceptable for our churches? These are questions that have been rolling around in my mind the last few years. And I have found that when you ask questions, some Anabaptist church members and ministers get very defensive and angry.

So I started studying history books instead to find answers. In the first half of the twentieth century, most American women still wore some type of head covering at least to church. So why did they start making the rules about the size, shape, and specific cloth? But at some point throughout that century, women began to drop the prayer caps. But Mennonite women who were members of the church continued to wear them to church.

Coffman that were referred to as the Seven Ordinances. The ordinances came at a time when Anabaptist women, as well as other woman in North America, wore coverings mainly to church. Interestingly enough , even the wife of J. Anabaptist history from previous centuries — regarding how much the head covering was worn and where all it was worn to—is unknown. While the head covering was practiced by the rest of the world, they did not bother giving much attention to Biblical arguments for the practice and application of the head covering.

Throughout the nineteenth century, Anabaptists were doing a lot of good things but apparently had forgotten why. The culture around them had good morals and did a lot of good things. But when the culture around them began to erode, they had to base their values on something else. But in doing this, they then faced the danger of holding traditions and rules as the reason for their religiosity. Coffman taught his list of ordinances because there was a desperate need for Biblical teaching.

His intention was to give the Biblical reason for our practices. For many, hearing 1Corinthians 11 expounded as the purpose for wearing the head covering was a wonderful revelation.

For many people it was the first that they had heard it taught. They have tried too much to do by force of law what grace alone can do. What is it worth to keep people down in any sense if they submit only by constraint? We are in the dispensation of grace, and I shall never again help to legislate on outward forms as I did once in the Virginia conference when I did not know better.

But I shall work harder in another way for the same principle. As the doctrinal significance of the seven ordinances brought renewed interest in these specific commands, the wearing of the head covering was also highlighted, and women began wearing it more often. Interestingly enough, the men were not instructed to never wear a hat using the same Scripture. Gradually, Anabaptist women began to wear it at meal times, family devotions, and then finally all the time.

It has remained as that ever since. The head covering then began to progressively be viewed as almost a mystical enigma among Anabaptists. Some Mennonite women began to view their head coverings as a banner of their religiosity and a symbol of status. For some groups, different covering styles or colors were used to signify the availability of a woman for marriage as old order Amish and some more conservative groups still do.

For others, it signified the wearer had been baptized and was a member of the church. Mennonite church leader and Professor Harold S. Bender gave a more orthodox justification for it in , when he wrote that the wearing of the covering was not of a moral or religious nature, but rather a social one. As dress codes and specific directives regarding head coverings for Anabaptist women began making their appearance throughout the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century, Anabaptist women began to look more and more differently from the rest of society.

Fashion changes in the late 19 th century included the demise of the Victorian-style bonnet and instead many women chose to wear a hat that was often decorated by feathers and flowers, etc. The bonnet was then prescribed by church leaders as being the only acceptable head gear.

Church leaders feared that if the bonnet was discarded by women, the covering would also be dropped. Bonnet enforcement by American Mennonite churches occurred earlier and more rigidly than in Canada —which was soon influenced by visiting American Mennonite evangelists Interestingly enough, Anabaptists of this time seemed to have forgotten that before the bonnets were in style, their ancestors wore flat hats.

Some of whom were very reluctant to accept bonnets. The enforcement of bonnet wearing caused much tension, angry debates, and conflict. The struggle became so angry that it resulted in a church split and the formation of Stirling Avenue Mennonite Church. A large number of women in this area had quit wearing the prescribed bonnets in favor of a hat while working at their factory jobs in town. Many single Mennonite women started working factory jobs that were vacated by the men because of the First World War.

As a result of this, the ministers and deacons in that area had a district meeting and passed a resolution that made wearing a bonnet a test of membership for women. When the district bishop refused to serve communion to anyone who did not agree with the resolution, a committee was assigned to investigate the situation.

This issue continued to be a source of contention for quite a number of years in this church and in , resulted in three ordained ministers being excommunicated and about one-third of the members leaving the church. When clothing stores no longer carried the out-of-fashion bonnet, women had to begin making their own. Many women gave resistance to the bonnets and to the caps through small acts of rebellion. Some would leave the strings hanging, rather than tying them, and some removed the strings altogether.

Some girls delayed their commitment to becoming a member of the Mennonite church so that they could wear the hat longer. Some modified the hats to make them look more like a bonnet by adding strings that tied under the chin. The historical periods of time when women were involved in non-farm occupations seemed to bring the most resistance to the bonnet. Many women chose to only wear the bonnet to church but refused to wear them to their jobs.

Many wear head coverings with strings attached, but hanging. If 1 Corinthians 11 is applying to every minute of every day than why do your Amish men wear hats.

Clearly that chapter is only referring to meeting times and not to the ordinary day. It is something that is special for when the church comes together and is meeting as a Body. I cover my head, and am intersted if anyone out here has a pattern for the black crocheted Mennonite covering that some older ladies in PA used to use? I have tried ot find it searching online, but not successful so far. Would love to find it! What method is used to starch a prayer coverings?

Please describe procedure from beginning to end and the ingredients needed. I need to starch a prayer covering which I own. I washed it and cannot get the crisp starch back into it. Thank you. There are a lot of former Amish that post in there so they will see your question and probably have an answer. As a born-again spirit-filled disciple of Jesus Christ, I find it quite disgraceful what the Amish men have their women do with their hair.

But instead of this, Amish women are forced to do the exact opposite and UNCOVER their heads, pinning all their hair up in and even hiding the hair under a covering, making them look masculine, ugly, self-sufficient and authoratitive.

Conviction will differ: when authority is identified as the woman's rather than as her husband's over her; when relationships in the body of Christ contrast rather than imitate those of the world.

Writers try to explain that role separation--symbolized through man's uncovered and woman's covered head--does not bless unequal value for woman and man.

But research Kraybill conducted among more than 1, Lancaster County , Pennsylvania , parents and youth shows how the veil has legitimated female subordination. It also verifies that decline in veil wearing does not degrade ethnic identity or diminish support for ethnic institutions. In addition to symbolic meanings of order and submission, women's headcovering traditionally fostered modesty, and opportunity for witness, particular identity and connection to worship. Late 20th century trends in Mennonite Church MC practice North America include discontinuing the wearing of a headcovering, allowing diverse practice side-by-side, and reinforcing the expectation that women have their heads covered during worship.

While more MC congregations based on studies in Indiana and Ohio support personal choice, which accommodates varied customs, other more conservative groups make even stronger appeals to conform to this expression of nonconformity. As more congregations called women to pastoral leadership, male power and one of its symbols was diminished. This, in turn, lead guardians of the tradition to buttress the claim that the prayer veil is of "Divine Order" and to remind Mennonite Church membership of Article 14 "Symbols of Christian Order" in the Mennonite Church's Confession of Faith.

The Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective no longer mentioned the headcovering. Mennonite churches worldwide also bring features of culture into patterns of headcovering.

Whereas Swiss Mennonite women throughout the 20th century have not used a prayer veiling, German Mennonite usage diminished in the second half of the 20th century. As a rite of passage from girl to woman, a ritual part of Russian Mennonite marriage has included her donning a kerchief. This symbol of subordination to one's husband is worn by some Mennonite Brethren women at all times. Mennonite women of India have naturally utilized the sari as headcovering for worship or expressing respect.

Differences and remarriage In addition, members of the Amish community are allowed to remarry after their spouse passes. There is a gender imbalance that occurs between widows and widowers within the Amish community, due to the facts that men tend to die earlier and that men also are more likely to remarry.

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel. Skip to content Home Philosophy What does the Mennonite bonnet mean? Ben Davis April 24, What does the Mennonite bonnet mean?

Why do Mennonites wear head coverings? Why do Mennonites wear cape dresses? Can Mennonites wear swimsuits?